Asked by Michael  |  Submitted April 15, 2014

Is it better to pay down my student loan or put money in a 401(k)?

I am in my early 30's and my student loan balance is around $40,000.

Report Question Report

  Leave Answer

Sign in to MoneyTips
By submitting you agree to our Terms of Service

  Answers  |  6

April 16, 2014

This is a very good question, Michael, and one that comes up frequently. As you look toward making other life decisions, you may have found that having a student loan payment can hinder your other plans like buying a home or saving for a down payment or retirement even.

Whether or not it makes sense to pay off the student loan in full really depends on a number of factors and your personal situation.

As a professional advisor, I would probably start by asking if you have an adequate emergency reserve. There are lots of opinions on this but I would say that a bare bones minimum would be three months of fixed living expenses (though I'd feel more comfortable with six months).

Then the next question would be what other priorities are you trying to meet: home purchase, paying down credit cards, weddings, etc.

So it depends on what your resources are as well as your cash flow. If you have sufficient cash flow, I would recommend the following priority for using it:
1.) pay yourself first - 10% preferably through retirement savings and non-retirement savings
2.) pay extra towards high interest credit cards - not deductible and very expensive
3.) pay extra towards the principal on your student loans - at least you may be able to get a tax deduction on the interest.

For something more specific to your situation, I recommend speaking with a financial planner - not necessarily one in your backyard just because they're close to you - but one who is going to provide unbiased advice not tied to the purchase of a product.

$commenter.renderDisplayableName() | 09.21.20 @ 06:14


July 15, 2014

I would dump the debt first. It will give you peace of mind when it is gone, otherwise, you will keep asking that same question every few months.

$commenter.renderDisplayableName() | 09.21.20 @ 06:14


January 16, 2015

Hi Michael! I'm a huge fan of paying off debt as soon as possible. You can't build your finances up if you are busy filling in a hole of debt. Make a plan to focus all your energies on paying down the debt in as short a time as possible. Do everything you can from downsizing your lifestyle, to doubling up on payments, to getting a second job. You can do this for a couple of years and be debt free. If you still want to save for retirement, try to at least save enough to get your full employer match, if available, or put some money in a Roth IRA. Good luck to you!

$commenter.renderDisplayableName() | 09.21.20 @ 06:14


November 24, 2015

I agree with those advisors who recommend that you see a professional advisor. That might sound silly, but the answer to your question, like almost all of these questions, is - it depends. Personal Financial Planning is just that - Personal. Generally, getting out of debt is great and frequently one of the top objectives. However, with student debt, I would ask questions like:

1. What type of debt is it (Federal or Private)
2. What type of job do you have
3. When did you incur the debt
4. How much money do you make
5. What are your life and professional goals

I work with a lot of teachers and other public servants. Many don't make a lot of money, but because of their jobs and the type of student loan debt they have, can take advantage of certain programs to have a substantial portion of their debt forgiven. If this describes your situation, then get with a financial advisor who understands this area well.

If you have a great job, make good money, then pay it off ASAP, after you save for an emergency fund and several months living expenses.

$commenter.renderDisplayableName() | 09.21.20 @ 06:14


December 09, 2015

Michael, paying down debt and investing for retirement are both prudent financial strategies. However, first and foremost, you should have emergency savings of three to six months of compensation to protect yourself from an expensive emergency or loss of employment. If you need money in an emergency, your lender will not refund you the extra payments which you have made on your loan and accessing the money in your 401(k) will result in taxes and penalties, if the money is accessible at all.

While each individual’s situation is unique, there are some general guidelines in what should be done before reducing student loan debt or begin investing in a 401(k):

1. Build emergency savings equal to three to six months of compensation.
2. Pay down any debt where the interest is not tax deductible such as credit cards.
3. Pay down any debt with high interest rates.
4. Verify that you are covered with sufficient liability limits for property casualty insurance (auto, home, renters, etc.)and have savings to meet deductibles.
5. Verify that you are sufficiently covered by health insurance and disability income insurance and have additional savings set aside for total out of pocket maximums and deductible periods.
6. Verify that you have enough life insurance for your dependents.
7. Verify that you do not have any big ticket expenses looming in your near future such as home purchase, car purchase, wedding, etc.

The prudent way isn’t sexy, but if you are covered above, you are ready to put your extra money to work. If I can assume that the student loan interest rate is not high, you are not adding to your loan balance, and you are making your payments. You will generally do better by investing in your 401(k) because you will get the benefit of compounding, growth on top of growth. Compounding is better the earlier you can start. How you allocate among your investment options within your 401(k) plan is something that you should first discuss with an investment professional.

There are some who will argue that debt reduction is always the best option for more reasons than just the financial ones. I believe that some debt (low interest rates and interest that may be tax deductible) is acceptable if the result is investing for retirement sooner than later.

$commenter.renderDisplayableName() | 09.21.20 @ 06:14


June 02, 2016

Simple: pay off the student loan before investing. No big explanation. When you are out of debt and able to save is the time to listen to a financial adviser.

$commenter.renderDisplayableName() | 09.21.20 @ 06:14