Getting There May Be Half The Fun, But Flying Back Is 97% Of The Price

The Mad Consumer on Airline Fees

Getting There May Be Half The Fun, But Flying Back Is 97% Of The Price
May 5, 2016

The night before I planned on flying to Hawaii with my family for spring break, we got the greatest invitation of our lives: would we like to fly there by private jet? DUH!

One minor problem: the kind offer was only one-way. My wife, two daughters, and I would still have to fly home on the domestic airline on which I had already spent $2768 on tickets. I won't tell you its name, but by domestic, I mean American.

At $692 apiece, those ducats sure sound expensive, but those were the cheapest we could find; to secure that "low" price, we had to book a redeye return flight. I've learned from experience that struggling to walk sleep-deprived through a cramped airplane aisle on cramping legs schlepping a carry-on, a dozing eight-year-old, and her carry-on is the best way to get the message, "Your vacation's over!"

On the phone, the airline representative told me that I couldn't just blow off the commercial flight to Hawaii and expect to get on the return flight. If I wanted to skip the first part of our trip with them, the airline would charge a $200 change fee.

Per ticket.

$800 to change our tickets from "there and back" to "back". How long would it take them to rip up half our tickets? Two minutes, tops? That $800 they would take out of the money I had already given them worked out to $24,000 an hour. Nice work if you can get it. Then, of course, they would resell our four outbound seats at last-minute prices and make more money!

What was in it for us? Between the change fee and the "new" one-way tickets, which cost $475 apiece, we would split the $2768 equally: they would keep the first two digits of $2700, and we would get the last two digits of $68. By not flying us for half of our trip, they would keep more than 97% of the money!

Would that whopping $68 be a refund to my credit card? HA! Just an airline credit. Would that be a $17 credit for the four of us individually? The rep wasn't sure, but I couldn't waste time; I had a private plane to catch.

Without making any changes, I hung up, huddled with my wife, and decided to press ahead with this I-hope-not-once-in-a-lifetime opportunity. As she called our generous hosts, I called back the airline to seal the deal.

As time passed on hold, my perception changed. My thinking went from, "We're giving up 4 of our 8 flights, and they’re going to give me a measly $68 credit back?" to "What if the prices have gone up and it's going to cost me more money for asking them NOT to fly us to Hawaii?" I had learned the hard way that some airline offers may be off the table minutes later. What if I had blown it by not accepting right away? (Because making family decisions without discussing them with your wife can be harmful to your health.)

Finally, a new airline rep confirmed we could still get the deal. Here’s where things get a little murky; I wanted to lock that in, while exploring other options. Greedy? Perhaps. Since we were exchanging round-trip for one-way tickets, could we use them on an earlier flight so I could avoid ending my vacation with the aforementioned, jet-lagged, break-of-dawn, child-and carry-on-juggling Walk O' Pain?

Sure, said the rep. We could have four $475 seats on an earlier flight.

For a $200 change fee.

Per ticket.


Nooooooooo! I argued that I was still in the process of changing our plans, but the rep said I had already rung up $800 in change fees, and that it would cost me another $800 to change plans again.

"Can I speak to your supervisor, please?"

BOOM! Immediately, my family and I were dropped into vacation limbo. If the phone had been disconnected, I wouldn’t know what tickets we had in which direction; all I had to hang on to was my anger, the feeling that I might have blown our private jet trip, and minute after painful minute of non-threatening jazz hold music.

After what seemed like an interminable wait, the same rep returned, and beneficently granted my wish: in return for keeping our money, they would fly us back, and issue us the pocket change credit. I couldn’t even use the credit to pay for our baggage fees on that flight!

Airline traveler complaints jumped 34 percent last year, to the highest level since 2000. Yet The Forbid Airlines from Imposing Ridiculous (FAIR) Fees Act, which would "prohibit air carriers from imposing fees that are not reasonable and proportional to the costs incurred by the air carriers," recently died in Congress.

"Airlines are overcharging consumers with fees that are grossly disproportionate to the value of the service received and result in a windfall for airlines. ‘Exhibit A’ is change fees, where airlines charge $200 when the true cost of a change is 6 to 7 times lower, if not zero," Business Travel Coalition founder Kevin Mitchell told Skift. "This kind of unconscionable consumer price gouging is a textbook example of unfair methods of competition that underpin competition laws."

Meanwhile, my tan is gone, and I’m still waiting for my $17 credit. Aloha.

  Conversation   |   6 Comments

Add a Comment

By submitting you agree to our Terms of Service
Victor | 05.05.16 @ 23:13
plane tickets are getting more expencive every day that is why people are resorting to holes in the airlines system in order to be able to buy them
Selena | 05.05.16 @ 23:22
I had no idea it was that difficult to change your plane tickets in the event that the ones you bought no longer worked out for you the way you needed them to. It wouldn't seem like it would cost the airlines that much to make a few, minor adjustments.
Kamie | 05.05.16 @ 23:27
That all seemed like a huge headache for what was supposed to be a nice vacation. Definitely a waste of hard earned money for sure! Flying has been the now expensive way to get places, but it is still the fastest. So, people will still pay for convince, but something like this does not seem much like a convenience.
STOKES | 05.05.16 @ 23:28
Plane trips are easier, but I prefer car trips. Cheaper and you see more. Also, no awkward exchanges with TSA.
Erin | 05.05.16 @ 23:31
I don't like the thought of having to travel anywhere by plane. It's such a hassle most of the time, and with as large a family as we have, driving has always been the better option. Of course, that limits where we can travel too. lol
Nancy | 05.05.16 @ 23:44
This story would be comical if it wasn't so ridiculous. The airlines get you coming and going. Pun intended.
$commenter.renderDisplayableName() | 01.23.21 @ 17:13