Unicorns And Wall Street

Growth Engines or Simply Overvalued?

Unicorns And Wall Street
September 15, 2016

There are unicorns on Wall Street? Indeed there are, but not the fictional beasts that are a favorite of pre-teen girls. As defined on Wall Street, unicorns are private companies that have valuations of over $1 billion. Generally, these are startups expected to create disruptive growth as they mature.

There are well over 100 unicorns worldwide. A Wall Street Journal/Dow Jones analysis lists 130 companies, CNN Money counts 141, and TechCrunch lists 191 with 53 others listed as emerging unicorns. They include well-known names like Uber, Lyft, Airbnb, SpaceX, Snapchat, Pinterest, Square, BuzzFeed, Dropbox, Warby Parker, FanDuel, and DraftKings — but there are also many that you are unlikely to have heard of, such as the IT security company Zscaler, data management group Actifio, and Klarna, a Swedish payment service for online storefronts.

Since they are all private, the information that investors need to evaluate any unicorn's value properly is not always available — or credible when it is. Thus, unicorns can have tremendous evaluations built mostly on hype and expectations.

Investors can be faced with difficult choices. Are you looking at the next Facebook, which had a market value of $104 billion upon going public in 2012, but is worth approximately $350 billion now? Are you looking at Zynga of FarmVille and Words with Friends fame, which lost over half of its value within three years after its initial public offering (IPO)? It is simply not easy to tell.

The collective value of the 191 companies listed on the TechCrunch site is $716 billion with over $116 billion in raised funds. Even with such cash reserves (and in some cases, because of it), many of the unicorns have been delaying IPOs.

Unicorns may become endangered if more of them do not start showing profits soon. Even Uber, with its massive $62-billion-plus valuation, will test investor's patience if it does not start showing signs of a profit in the next few years.

Cracks are starting to show in terms of pre-IPO devaluations. Dropbox and Snapchat have seen a nearly one-quarter drop in their pre-IPO valuations, while Square's pre-IPO value has dropped by approximately one-third. Larger investors and venture capitalists are sending a message to the unicorns: Outline a solid path to profits and start producing them soon, or expect your valuation to be slashed.

Diving ahead with an IPO is not necessarily the best path, either. Companies who have forged ahead with recent IPOs have not fared well. For example, global e-commerce marketplace Groupon is down around 78% since its IPO, and domestic issue Fitbit (NYSE: FIT) dropped 31% in the first half of November.

If you are considering investing in one of the unicorns that crosses over to public status via an IPO, be sure to read over the investment details carefully. Around 30% of the unicorns have so-called "ratchet clauses" that favor certain large and privileged investors. Ratchet clauses effectively reallocate additional shares to the privileged investors if the IPO price does not meet a pre-determined minimum value. This reduces the risk for special investors by diverting it to ordinary investors, who have their ownership shares diluted as a result.

It seems inevitable that the collective overvaluation will take down a sizable number of the current crop of unicorns, but those who survive are likely to provide great rewards. Don’t let the risks scare you away from investing in unicorns that you think will succeed, but make sure you understand the level of risk involved and can determine a proper pricing level.


Photo ©iStock.com/Redrockschool

  Conversation   |   5 Comments

Add a Comment

By submitting you agree to our Terms of Service
trish | 09.15.16 @ 17:11
The point of investing in these unicorns is what I fear most. As it says Facebook keeps growing while things like candy crush and FarmVille were so hot and are fading. How do you choose the right one? I am too scared to risk my money on a guess
Zanna | 09.15.16 @ 17:16
These are private companies with investments fueled by hype and expectations. Many are delaying IPOs because they're not really earning much money, if any. They're called unicorns for a reason, many people believe in them, but the chances of catching one, ie: seeing a profit from them is very rare.
Carla Truett | 09.15.16 @ 17:26
If you have the extra money to lose, then I would say go for it. I myself don't have enough to feel secure enough to invest in Unicorn companies. It is a gamble no matter how you look at it. I'm surprised Words with Friends went down as much as it did. I still play that one but very few of my friends do. I would have banked on that one and lost.
Christina | 09.15.16 @ 18:00
They're called unicorns for a reason - the chance that they will perform and show a profit is rare indeed. They do exist, but it takes a very specific knowledge to be confident in investing in one!
Leah Gardner | 09.16.16 @ 03:21
It seems almost too risky. The idea of investment is tempting. But the chance that it may fail or that one of these companies will suddenly stop or disappear isn't worth the risk.
$commenter.renderDisplayableName() | 12.04.16 @ 01:55
{comment}

  Our Professionals Are Available to Help!

  Can't find What You're Looking For?