Should Couples File Taxes Jointly or Separately?

Which is Best for You?

Should Couples File Taxes Jointly or Separately?
March 10, 2016

Married couples have the choice of filing their taxes jointly or separately. What is the best option for you and your spouse? Generally, it is to file jointly – but there are several factors to consider before making your choice.

Obviously, the first hurdle is that you have to be married. For tax purposes, you are considered married if you were married on the last day of the tax year, even if you are in the process of a divorce that has not yet been finalized. Joint filing status is not available to couples in civil unions or domestic partnerships.

Thanks to the Supreme Court, married same-sex couples must file their federal taxes jointly or as a married couple filing separately – single status is not an option. However, state taxes may differ since some states do not recognize same-sex marriage. If you are part of a same-sex married couple, check the state where you live for the current tax rules.

Assuming you meet the marriage criteria, how do you decide? Start by considering the disadvantages of filing separately and think of how many apply to your situation. Keep in mind that if you file separately, you and your spouse must choose to both take the standard deduction or both itemize – you cannot take separate approaches.

  • Tax Rates – Filing separately shifts your tax rate downward. In other words, higher tax rates will kick in at lower levels of income.

  • Deductions – Your standard deductions drop significantly when filing separately, and many itemized deductions are reduced through income phase-outs or eliminated entirely. Check the instructions for Schedule A and Form 1040 to determine how large the difference will be based on your income. Further details may be found on IRS Publication 501, “Exemptions, Standard Deductions, and Filing Information.”

  • Credits – Filing separately reduces or eliminates potential tax credits that are subtracted directly from your tax bill. For example, you cannot take the Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC), the Elderly or Disabled Credit, or the educational credits (American Opportunity Credit or Lifetime Learning Credit). The Child Tax Credit is still available but significantly reduced when filing separately.
  • Alternative Minimum Tax – Filing separately cuts your Alternative Minimum Tax (AMT) exemption in half, and makes it more likely that you will have to pay the AMT (which eliminates or reduces many deductions).

  • Benefits – Generally, more of your Social Security benefits are taxable when you file separately. When filing jointly, you and your spouse must combine incomes and benefits to determine the taxable portion of benefits, even if you or your spouse receives no benefits.

  • Community Property – Community property states such as California and Texas dictate which property is considered separate or joint (“community”) for tax purposes. Should you both itemize, you may be faced with a hideous pile of paperwork to split assets 50/50.

Those are pretty powerful arguments to file jointly. However, there are a few reasons to consider filing separately.

  • Questionable Tax Practices – You should file separately if your spouse is stretching, or outright breaking, the tax laws. Signing a joint return makes you responsible for paying any taxes, penalties, and fines that your spouse incurs but refuses to pay.

  • Separation/Divorce – Separating your finances as part of an in-process separation or divorce lends itself to also filing your taxes separately.

  • Income Adjustment – When itemized deductions require a threshold expense compared to income, filing separately makes sense if the savings are large enough. Consider a couple with a wide income gap and large out-of-pocket medical expenses. Jointly they would not be able to meet the 10% threshold, but the spouse with the lower income may be able to qualify separately and deduct some of the expenses.

If you are not sure, do a trial run of your taxes both ways. However, most couples will find filing jointly to be the simpler and most economical path.


Photo ©iStock.com/Ridofranz

  Conversation   |   13 Comments

Add a Comment

By submitting you agree to our Terms of Service
Steffanie | 03.09.16 @ 18:49
We always file jointly, never considered trying it separately. Together seems much easier.
Alec | 03.09.16 @ 18:49
My husband and I did the work for filing separately and jointly to decide which was best. We filed jointly this year because we got more back. I think we will keep checking every year when our financial situation is different just to make sure though.
Carla Truett | 03.09.16 @ 18:49
We weighed the option of filing separately but we came out far better by filing jointly. I do recommend that couples check to see which is best for them individually.
Elaine | 03.09.16 @ 18:50
Interesting information about when to file jointly or separate. I would rather just file the easy way and avoid all the hurdles.
trish | 03.09.16 @ 18:51
we have always filed jointly, but our accountant always tries both ways to see which one we benefit from more. So far, has always been jointly.
Erin | 03.09.16 @ 18:52
We have run the numbers both ways, and we come out so much further ahead if we file jointly. It was amazing the difference in numbers, really. It's kind of crazy how much you may be able to save by filing jointly.
Ron | 03.09.16 @ 18:54
We have never benefited from filing separately. We did compare the first few years and it never was beneficial. In fact, we would have owed money the first few years if had filed separately. I do wonder that if a Fair Tax type code ever replaces our current one, if that would impact these decisions due to prebates and any held over deductions.
Sara | 03.09.16 @ 18:58
We always file jointly and have never done separately. IT never worked out when we tried separately.
Katie | 03.09.16 @ 18:59
We file jointly. One year I actually played around with filing separately. We would have lost a lot of money. We are lower income and we rely heavily on our taxes to add to our savings each year. So we do file jointly each year. We will continue to do so unless we find that it will benefit us to file separately.
Jane | 03.09.16 @ 19:01
I wasn't aware that filing separately still carried so many disadvantages. It's good to be able to read, all in one place, the advantages of filing jointly. We always file jointly, and I feel much better about it after reading this article.
connie | 03.09.16 @ 19:06
As a married woman I have never filed separately and really never understood why a married couple would consider doing so. I did, however find the article informative. Filing separately due to questionable tax practices could be a lifesaver for a married couple if one of them is breaking the tax laws.
Irene | 03.09.16 @ 19:09
We've always filed jointly, it works out better for us that way plus it's easier to not have to do 2 returns.
Leslie | 03.09.16 @ 19:10
My husband and I have explored filing separately, but we get more back if we file together because we get more of the tax breaks that are listed in the article.
$commenter.renderDisplayableName() | 12.06.16 @ 22:04
{comment}

  Our Professionals Are Available to Help!

  Can't find What You're Looking For?